One night in November, unknown persons climb through a tilted window into an engineering office. They take six notebooks, the coffee fund and a small storage system from the open server cabinet. The thieves want devices to resell; the data means nothing to them. The storage system, however, held the unencrypted backups of every project from the last ten years, and no second copy existed. The thief cares about resale value. The real damage comes from the data that leaves with the device.
This risk source stands for perpetrators who act without IT skills: thieves, burglars, vandals and arsonists. ISO/IEC 27005 does not list them separately in the table of attacker profiles in Annex A, because that table concentrates on cyber attacks. In its list of typical threats, though, the standard marks theft of devices and media as a deliberate act, and fire or water can also be caused on purpose there.
What is behind it?
This covers opportunistic thieves on trains, in cafés and in cars, burglars in offices and warehouses, vandals and arsonists. Some act out of need or greed, others out of anger, boredom or a desire to destroy. They are almost never after information, and still data regularly ends up with them, because it travels on the devices.
Resources and approach
- Opportunity. A notebook on the passenger seat, an open door to the warehouse, a tilted window on the ground floor.
- Break-ins. Doors and windows forced open, often at night or at weekends when nobody is in the building.
- Tailgating. In office buildings with many tenants, a stranger in the corridor rarely stands out.
- Destruction. Vandals damage devices, empty fire extinguishers or open taps; arsonists set fire to bins, vehicles or stock.
- Material theft. Thieves of copper cable or metal parts put lines and installations out of action as a side effect.
Impact
Availability suffers most often: devices are gone, rooms unusable, data without backup lost. Confidentiality suffers as soon as unencrypted devices or paper files fall into the wrong hands. A fire often affects the whole building, and the extinguishing water frequently destroys more equipment than the fire itself. The value of the devices is usually the smallest item. Downtime, recovery and possibly a data breach cost more.
Practical examples
Notebook from the car. A field sales employee leaves her notebook in the car over lunch. The window is smashed, notebook and bag are gone. Because the hard disk is fully encrypted and all data is on the server, the loss is limited to the device. A USB stick with an unencrypted customer list in the same bag still makes a notification necessary.
Arson in the yard. At night, unknown persons set fire to delivery vans in the company yard. The fire spreads to the adjacent warehouse, on whose upper floor the server room is located. The fire brigade prevents worse, yet the extinguishing water runs through the ceiling into the racks.
Vandalism after the break-in. After a failed break-in, the frustrated intruders empty several powder extinguishers in the offices. The fine powder gets into computers and network cabinets. Weeks later, failures pile up because contacts corrode.
Typical threats
This risk source typically triggers these BSI elementary threats:
- G 0.16 Theft of Devices, Storage Media or Documents: the most common case, in the office and on the move.
- G 0.24 Destruction of Devices or Storage Media: vandalism and wilful damage.
- G 0.1 Fire: arson on buildings, vehicles or stock.
- G 0.3 Water: opened pipes and extinguishing water after a fire.
- G 0.4 Contamination, Dust, Corrosion: extinguishing powder and dirt after vandalism.
Effective controls
Prevention:
- A.7.1 Physical Security Perimeters: securing windows, doors and the building shell as far as the protection needs require.
- A.7.2 Physical Entry: controlling entry, accompanying visitors, locking technical rooms.
- A.7.9 Security of Assets Off-Premises: rules for devices on the move, in the car and when working from home.
- A.8.24 Use of Cryptography: full encryption of endpoints and storage media.
Detection:
- A.7.4 Physical Security Monitoring: intruder alarm, cameras at critical points, alerting outside working hours.
Response:
- A.6.8 Information Security Event Reporting: reporting loss and theft immediately so devices can be locked and wiped.
- A.8.13 Information Backup: backups at another location, so that a break-in or fire does not hit every copy.
Risk sources in ISO 27005
ISO/IEC 27005 defines a risk source as anything that, on its own or together with other factors, can lead to a risk, and it distinguishes human, environmental and technical sources. Human sources can act intentionally or unintentionally. The table of attacker profiles in Annex A is only a collection of examples, and in clause 10.1 the standard recommends considering all internal and external risk sources. The product catalogue therefore adds petty criminals as a source of their own. In the list of typical threats in Table A.10, fire, water and dust or corrosion carry the markers for deliberate, accidental and environmental, while theft of media, documents and equipment carries only the marker for deliberate. In the asset-based approach you come across this source quite naturally as soon as you look at buildings, rooms and mobile devices as supporting assets (→ ISO/IEC 27005 Information Security Risk Management).
Sources
- ISO/IEC 27005:2022, definitions 3.1.6 and 3.2.7, clause 10.1 and Annex A.2.5.1: risk sources and typical threats
- BSI IT-Grundschutz Compendium: elementary threats G 0.1 to G 0.24
- ISO/IEC 27002:2022, clauses 6.8, 7.1, 7.2, 7.4, 7.9, 8.13 and 8.24
- General Data Protection Regulation, Art. 33 and 34: notification and communication of data breaches