A tax advisory firm replaces its laptops and donates the old ones to a sports club after a quick format. A youth coach tries out a free recovery program and finds payslips, tax assessments and scanned identity cards of clients. In the same month, misprints with bank details end up in the firm’s ordinary paper recycling. A.1.4.9 requires documented policies, procedures or mechanisms for disposing of personal data, using a technique that suits the type of data and the medium.
Disposal is the last step in the life cycle and at the same time the one in which the data leaves the protected environment. Whatever goes wrong here cannot be undone.
What does the standard require?
The control itself is brief: there are documented policies, procedures or mechanisms for disposing of personal data. The implementation guidance explains what matters when choosing the technique.
- Techniques differ. Methods deliver different results, for instance in how small the remnants of a physical medium end up or whether deleted data on electronic media can be recovered.
- Type and extent of the data. A single printout of a phone list calls for different handling than an archive of health data.
- Metadata. It has to be checked whether the data comes with metadata that must disappear as well.
- Properties of the medium. Paper, magnetic hard drives, SSDs, tapes and smartphones behave differently in physical terms and each need methods of their own.
The standard names these criteria as a minimum selection; others may be added.
In practice
Set methods per medium. Paper is shredded in document shredders or by a service provider. In Germany, DIN 66399 has become the yardstick for the level of shredding. Conventional hard drives can be overwritten completely. For SSDs and flash memory, overwriting is unreliable because of internal storage management, so the built-in erase commands, cryptographic erasure or physical destruction apply. For cloud storage, deleting the keys of encrypted data works well, supplemented by the provider’s assurance. NIST SP 800-88 often serves as the technical reference for sanitizing electronic media.
Think of metadata. Thumbnails, search indexes, document properties, logs of file access and copies in mailboxes belong to the scope of disposal.
Choose service providers carefully. Disposal companies receive locked containers and a contract with rules on data processing, and they deliver a certificate of destruction for each job. For devices, serial numbers belong in the certificate.
Secure the chain of custody. Between decommissioning and destruction, devices and files are stored under lock. Whoever decommissions something documents it, and whoever collects it signs for it.
Enable employees. Clearly visible confidential waste bins, a short instruction next to the printer and a clear contact point for retired devices prevent most everyday mistakes.
Typical audit evidence
For A.1.4.9, auditors typically expect:
- Disposal policy with a method per medium and protection level (→ Data Deletion, Masking & Leakage Prevention Policy)
- Contracts with disposal providers, including the data processing terms (→ Supplier Register)
- Certificates of destruction with date, quantity or serial numbers and method (→ Deletion Evidence Log)
- Evidence of device decommissioning in line with A.7.14 Secure Disposal or Re-Use of Equipment
- Locked collection containers and storage areas, described in the Physical Security Policy
KPI
% of PII disposals performed using verified secure destruction methods
Verified means: there is a record for the disposal that names method, date and item, and the method matches the matrix. The target is 100%. The figure is easy to test against retired devices: for every device that has left the asset register, a record must exist.
Supporting KPIs:
- Share of retired devices with a deletion record per serial number
- Number of collections by the service provider with a complete certificate of destruction
- Number of personal documents found in ordinary waste during spot checks
Link to the GDPR
Under Article 4(2) GDPR, erasure and destruction are themselves processing of personal data. The same principles therefore apply to them, above all integrity and confidentiality under Article 5(1)(f). Article 32(1)(b) and 32(2) require measures against unauthorized disclosure, and faulty disposal is a classic route to it. If a service provider handles destruction, it usually acts as a processor under Article 28. If data reaches unauthorized people through faulty disposal, there is usually a personal data breach that has to be assessed under Article 33 and notified where required (→ GDPR General Data Protection Regulation).
Related controls
A.1.4.9 sets how data disappears, while the neighbouring controls decide when:
- A.1.4.6 PII de-identification and deletion at the end of processing: triggers deletion once the purpose is fulfilled.
- A.1.4.8 Retention: supplies the periods after which disposal takes place.
- A.2.4.3 Return, transfer or disposal of PII: governs disposal at the processor when the contract ends.
- A.7.14 Secure Disposal or Re-Use of Equipment: covers devices that are retired or reused.
- A.7.10 Storage Media: governs the handling of storage media throughout their use.
Sources
- ISO/IEC 27701:2025, Annex A, Table A.1, A.1.4.9, and Annex B, B.1.4.9: Disposal
- DIN 66399 (destruction of data carriers) and NIST SP 800-88 (Guidelines for Media Sanitization)
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Articles 4, 5, 28, 32 and 33
- ISO/IEC 27701: Privacy Information Management System: structure of the standard and roles